(by Thomas) The article in yesterday’s newspaper got many things right. There were, however, some misleading terms that cloud the dialogue. The two “C” words, for example, “Christian” and “convert”. I’d like to set the record straight and deepen the dialogue for those willing to wade past the confusion and labels handed down for centuries. Let’s Clarify Our Terms – I Am A Jew!
As far as whether I am a Christian, as the caption in the picture noted, let me be clear. I was born a Jew. I became a Bar Mitzvah, was confirmed in Temple, went to Israel with a team of Jewish college youth from around the country, was married under a Chuppah, both of my parents and all my grandparents were Jewish. Hitler would have killed me without thinking twice. I love my Tanakh (a.k.a. Old Testament) and I love the G-d Who is in it. I also believe with all my heart that these writings of the family of Israel point to a Messiah, who will one day rule the world as King. Furthermore, I believe the identity of this Messiah is a Jewish man who walked the earth roughly 2000 years ago. There were many like me who became convinced to follow him as he taught, healed, and exposed the hearts of many. He was a Jew and he came to the Jews. His followers were primarily Jews and many of them wrote about him, and wrote to others about him. We have these writings as additional writings of the family of Israel that confirm the identity of this Messiah (a.k.a. New Testament). So, if by the term “Christian” you mean do I love and follow Yeshua as Messiah and do I believe that ALL the writings of the family of Israel, given not just to enlighten the Jews but all the world, are true and trustworthy, then the I will not protest that label. If, on the other hand, you mean am I no longer Jewish, then I reject equally wholeheartedly the meaning and implication of such a label. I am a Jew. I am a Jew who believes in Messiah. I am a Jew who believes that Yeshua is the Messiah.
In other words, the term “Christian” means different things to different people. In fact, if you ask 10 people around Nashville what the term means, you will likely get quite different answers. Evangelical, mainline Protestant, Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Jewish, Agnostic, Atheist. Each will have a different way of “unpacking” or defining this label. Unfortunately, labels often get used to clarify exactly who is “US” and who is “THEM”. The history of Christianity is tragically filled with repeated wars and murders against those who did not have the same definitions or theology. Oftentimes, this division was an “in house” debate between people who all wore the same label, “Christian”, but viewed themselves as the REAL kind while others were not.
This issue of my identifying myself as a Jew is an “in house” debate as well. Jews do not agree on what is the definition of a Jew. Which brings me to the second word “convert.” The article said I converted in college. Well, if by this term we mean “teshuva”, the Hebrew word for repentance, or literally “turning away and going the other direction” the only conversion I underwent was turning away from my rebellion against G-d and turning and running back TO Him. In other words, while you could say I converted from my sin back to G-d, it would be totally inaccurate, misleading and untrue to say that I converted from one religion to another. Religion is man’s path to try and reach G-d. I believe G-d is more interested in having a relationship with people. So, I did not convert away from being a Jew. Yeshua did not call the people of Israel to turn away from being Jews. To imply as much by using this common term “convert” only serves to keep the dialogue on a more superficial level and helps preserve the religious “status quo” where many Jews and Christians are quite comfortable, but perhaps only seeing through a glass dimly. Let’s deepen the dialogue and try to see more clearly. The fruit of such an endeavor can be love. Indeed that is what has happened with my father and me. To what degree is love the fruit of your dialogue with those with whom you may disagree? Why not commit to pursue this love at whatever cost. 1 Corinthians 13 exhorts us that “the GREATEST of these is love!”
Filed under: Uncategorized | 3 Comments »